Scones and Sensibility
My seven year old daughter picked this one out at the bookstore. When we got home I read the back cover and asked her if she liked romance as the book was all about romance. She giggled and said that she liked romance a little. I told her that I'd read it and see if I thought it was something she would like but that I thought she probably would want to wait till she was a little older but if she really wanted to she could read it. After reading it I told her what it was about and how it was difficult to read and she decided that it could wait a few years.
Appropriateness: There isn't any adult material in the book and the romance is tame enough that a young child would not be put off by it, the romance is mostly matchmaking. However, because Polly talks like she is in the 1800's it is not an easy read. The publisher lists it as at a mid fifth grade level. I would recommend it to romantic 11-14 year olds who are looking for a sweet fun romance.